Continuously excellent slices, Satisfaction level is tops, The "Macho Slice is really delicious and with a nice spicy flavor. Complex toppings. Also the Barbecue Chicken slice is crispy excellent, The Margarita slice Excellent and the Plain slice is excellent. Something special about the dough, crispy, crunchy, tasty, satisfying. Wish I could have these slices more often, as I am generally out of town. Recommend!

Get their chipotle chicken ranch pizza. Best in nyc! Dave Portnoy didn't give it an 8+ rating for no reason!

Freddie & Pepper's is such a solid New York slice --the crust is perfectly thin and crispy every time. I often grab a late night slice on my walk home and the guys are so helpful and quick! It's your classic and very reasonable slice counter, that almost feels "hole-in the wall". Huge fan!

Four slices and two bottled sodas, came out to about 30 bucks for big slices. The staff were busy, but at least able to tell me what each pizza had in it. The atmosphere is typical New York and you have to come down a few stairs to come in to a small little seating area. There is about two tables and four chairs outside. Not a bad spot to hit when in New York City.

I was walking down the street when I stumbled on this pizza place and wow I'm glad I did I had 2 slices and hands down best pizza I ever tasted definitely coming back and I and not to mention the friendly service from all staff

Great NY pizza in the Upper Westside. Quick service, great crust and perfect cook. Small area to dine in put a great stop for a slice of pie.

Probably the best texture of pizza i've ever had! The slices were cooked to absolute perfection. While it was not the very best margherita slice i've had, I still very much enjoyed Freddie & Peppers. The cheese slice was a little too light on the sauce or else it would have been crowned the best in my book.

I have been coming to Freddie & Pepper's since I was seven and I have recently fallen in love with this pizza place all over again. I used to come visit with my school, Stephen Gaynor, when they were in the neighborhood. We used to order pizza every Friday. I have gone to other Pizza places all over New York, and I was looking for that happy feeling I got from Freddie & Pepper's. No matter where I went I couldn't find it. When I came back, that same warm feeling of nostalgic gold came back and I got exactly what I was looking for. I also noticed a hidden gem within the hidden gem. On the wall near the pictures of the celebrities that have also come and enjoyed the pizza, there is a class picture from Stephen Gaynor in 1993. I'm not the only alumnus who feels that feeling of bliss when they come and enjoy the delicious pizza that is made by the kind and passionate people who work here. It is a testament to the fact that Freddie & Pepper's is a unique staple to the Upper West Side. Although there have been days that were not as good as others, every trip is worth the visit. I will definitely keep coming back.

I went here with my girlfriend to have some pizza. They have some good vegan/whole-wheat options. Pepperoni Chicken Bacon Ranch Seafood Zucchini The Chicken Bacon Ranch was the best!